India News
Search Web Directory
News Home
Corporate governance lessons from IDBI-LIC deal and ICICI Bank
Posted on 9th July 2018
Two recent events in the financial sector offer many corporate governance lessons. In one case, the government and its agencies were involved and left behind questionable precedents. In another private sector institution, a former government employee is involved though the manner of his involvement raises questions. These events are juxtaposed with larger societal questions related to saving institutions and jobs and ensuring financial stability.

The first example relates to the government’s decision to sell its stake in IDBI Bank to the Life Insurance Corp. of India (LIC). IDBI Bank’s non-performing assets (NPAs) have been mounting, as have been its losses. Its capital adequacy barely meets the regulatory benchmarks. In short, the bank is floundering without a visible lifeline. The government, as the largest shareholder, provided one tranche of capital infusion but clearly that was not enough.

Thereafter, the government was faced with three choices. One, to provide more capital. But the government’s kitty is limited and must deal with competing claims. Two, it could extinguish the legal entity by either merging it with a stronger public sector bank or shutting it down. The former option involves consciously infecting another public sector bank with IDBI’s bugs. Shutting it down, on the other hand, is a political risk in a pre-election year. Three, the government could sell it off, but no private sector bank would want to risk it. The next best solution: force-feed it to another public sector entity which cannot say no to the government.

Enter LIC, the government’s preferred sick bay for ailing public sector banks, especially those which the government does not want to (or cannot) recapitalize, downsize or shut down. The transaction raises multiple questions about acceptable corporate governance norms.

First, how did LIC get the money to pay the government for its stake in IDBI Bank? Any money it pays out has to be from policyholders’ funds, or the premium they pay to the insurance company every so often. Ideally, any excess money belongs to policyholders and must be returned to them after deducting expenses and provisions. This then raises ethical questions: are the funds invested in IDBI Bank sourced from the surplus which should have been returned to policyholders but has now been diverted? Also, theoretically, LIC’s investment in IDBI Bank breaches the investment mandate approved by government and regulator.

The other issue is the regulator’s discretionary powers. The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (IRDAI) seems to have approved the IDBI-LIC deal in record time. In most other cases, IRDAI takes its time in assessing risks to policyholders and the impact any proposed deal is likely to have on the industry and its stability. The speed at which the IDBI-LIC deal was approved seems to indicate that an inherent hierarchical priority has been superimposed over the regulator’s approval process, which accords undue urgency to deals involving the government. This is a dangerous precedent.

It can be argued that saving the bank is part of the sovereign’s social and moral contract: It is duty-bound to ensure financial stability (which includes safety of depositors’ money), save jobs and make all efforts to ensure asset turnaround. And, the argument goes, the government can circumvent some of the rules for this purpose.

Focusing on asset turnaround is also the philosophical keystone for the current bankruptcy and resolution process. The Committee Report on Resolution of Stressed Assets, or Sashakt, also echoes similar values. If we consider IDBI Bank to be a stressed asset, then its resolution process contradicts some of the committee’s suggestions: transparent market-based solution, free from government intervention, paradigm shift in governance and risk process.

The second example where corporate governance questions arise relate to ICICI Bank and the raging debate over the board’s embarrassing flip-flops. The same board seems to have now waded into deeper, murkier waters in their attempts to ameliorate the early situation.

The board belatedly, and probably under pressure, has agreed to an independent probe into allegations of impropriety by chief executive Chanda Kochhar, who is on leave till the enquiry is complete. Thereafter, the board’s process for selecting a new chief operating officer (COO) designate in Sandeep Bakhshi seemed as arbitrary and opaque. Interestingly, the press release announcing the board’s decision to appoint Bakhshi as COO includes an intriguing statement: “Mr Bakhshi will report to Ms Chanda Kochhar, who will continue in her role as MD & CEO of ICICI Bank...During her period of leave, the COO will report to the Board.” If Bakhshi has to report to Kochhar for the next five years, assuming she gets a clean chit, how much discretion and independence will he exercise now?

That brings us to the new chairman. Former bureaucrat Girish Chaturvedi has been appointed as the new chairman though it is unclear how the selection was made. Was there any government intervention? The ICICI Bank board is yet to share the processes it adopted for selecting Chaturvedi. There are also news reports of Chaturvedi and Bakshi having interacted earlier—as insurance secretary and chief executive officer (CEO) of ICICI Lombard, respectively. While it is good for any company to have the CEO and chairman acting in harmony, it is also true that too much familiarity breeds multiple evils, especially of the corporate governance type.

Related Companies: ICICI Bank   

Other Latest News
Yes Bank board meeting advanced to 13 December amid crisis
Posted on 21st November 2018
Mumbai: Yes Bank Ltd on Wednesday said its board will meet on 13 December to consider appointment of a new chairman, two independent directors to replace departing directors, and the CEO search panel’s recommendation to appoint a successor to the current MD and CEO Rana Kapoor. The bank also said that its promoters are seeking a mutual resolution to ensure better support and coordination for outstanding issues.

Sensex falls over 200 points on weak global cues
Posted on 21st November 2018
The BSE benchmark Sensex fell over 200 points in early trade on Wednesday following weak global cues amid fresh foreign fund outflows.

The 30-share was trading 215.44 points, or 0.61 per cent, lower at 35,259.07 points. The gauge had lost 300.37 points Tuesday.

L&T, Kotak, NBCC, two others submit EoI for JIL
Posted on 21st November 2018
State-owned NBCC, Cube Highways & Infrastructure, L&T Infrastructure, Kotak Investment Advisors and Suraksha Asset Reconstruction along with Lakshdeep Investments and Finance and Suraksha Realty have submitted their expression of interest for the bankrupt Jaypee Infratech (JIL). These firms have been provisionally shortlisted by the resolution professional and will subsequently be asked to submit their resolution plans.

Reserve Bank of India: Banks may get Rs 13,400 crore capital exemption
Posted on 21st November 2018
Indian banks may get a reprieve of about Rs 13,400 crore in capital exemption, as announced by the Reserve Bank of India board on Monday. The biggest beneficiary of this would be the government, because the RBI decision would lessen the burden on it to bridge a capital shortage at several state-run banks.

Reliance Jio launches international roaming services in India
Posted on 21st November 2018
Reliance Jio on Monday launched VoLTE-based inbound international roaming services between India and Japan, whereby international travellers visiting the country will be able to enjoy its high speed LTE network.

Japan-based KDDI Corporation is the first international mobile service provider to avail of Jio’s VoLTE calling and LTE data international roaming service.

» Post a FREE Classified Advertisement
Inviting Real Estate Agents, Job Placements Agents, Educational Institutes, Software Service Providers, Real Estate Builders, Marriage Bureaus, Travel Agents, Restaurant Owners, Health & Fitness Centers and other Local Businesses to Post a FREE Classified Advertisement on Classifieds Website.
Jobs in India India Real Estate Automobiles Matrimonials Beauty & Fitness

Add a comment for Corporate governance lessons from IDBI-LIC deal and ICICI Bank
Please only use this form to enter comments on the above company. All comments are reviewed before they are displayed on the web site. Not all comments may be displayed. Check back with us to see if your comments have been displayed.
If you want us to email the comments posted by users, please Subscribe by email
Security Code*

Be the first person to write a business review for Corporate governance lessons from IDBI-LIC deal and ICICI Bank

Most Read News

Sensex, Nifty end higher for 2nd session on strong fund inflow, firm rupee

GVK Power gets approval to raise Rs 8,000 crore for debt repayment

Markets post third straight weekly gain; YES Bank stock declines 7%

Coal India share sale to employees receives a lukewarm response

NPA burden on power sector

More India News

Photo Gallery

A. R. Rahman(13 Images) A. R. Rahman
Rudhramadevi(13 Images)Rudhramadevi
  India Web Directory
Business Profiles
Automotive Directory
IT/ITES/BPO Directory
Hotel Directory
Health Directory
Business Directory
Gems & Jewellery
Education Directory
Real Estate Directory
Agriculture Directory
Logistics Directory
Yellow Pages
NRI Guide
Photo Galleries
Global Web Directory
*** FREE India Classifieds
Order Premium Listings
Submit a Site
Business Reviews
About us
Link to us
Contact us
Google Search Keywords: India Catalog, IndiaCatalog, India Web Directory
    © 1999 - 2018
    All Rights Reserved
Privacy Statement